Text chat: seven non-blocking design questions #286

Open
opened 2026-11-12 11:08:12 +00:00 by charles · 1 comment
Owner

Seven choices in the Text chat spec (§17) that you can overrule. The recommended option is what is being built; nothing waits on the answers. Reply per number.

  • Q1 — Synced picker preferences. Read and write the picker frecency, favourites, skin tone
    and favourite GIFs in synced_preferences (so they match the Electron app), with a
    hand-written protobuf codec that preserves every other field. Alternative: keep them local
    to the native client (no risk of clobbering other preferences; no sync).
  • Q2 — Video playback. No in-window video in this sub-project: posters open the system
    player/browser. Alternative: embed a decoder (GStreamer or ffmpeg) now, a large dependency.
  • Q3 — Voice messages. Play them here (waveform player); recording waits for sub-project 7.
    Alternative: build recording now (needs an Opus/OGG encoder dependency).
  • Q4 — Threads depth. Build reading, posting, the chip, the side panel, creating from a
    message and the sidebar list; leave forums, thread browser filters and thread settings to 7.
    Alternative: everything now.
  • Q5 — Search engines, translators, reverse image search. Move these three chat-settings
    items and their context-menu entries to sub-project 7. Alternative: build them now.
  • Q6 — Composer pills. Accept coloured text instead of atomic pills (§15). Alternative: a
    custom editor widget (weeks of work, high risk).
  • Q7 — Soundboard favourites (#92). Sync them through the same soundboard_picker field of
    synced preferences in this sub-project. Alternative: keep them local.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

Seven choices in the Text chat spec (§17) that you can overrule. The recommended option is what is being built; nothing waits on the answers. Reply per number. - **Q1 — Synced picker preferences.** Read and write the picker frecency, favourites, skin tone and favourite GIFs in `synced_preferences` (so they match the Electron app), with a hand-written protobuf codec that preserves every other field. Alternative: keep them local to the native client (no risk of clobbering other preferences; no sync). - **Q2 — Video playback.** No in-window video in this sub-project: posters open the system player/browser. Alternative: embed a decoder (GStreamer or ffmpeg) now, a large dependency. - **Q3 — Voice messages.** Play them here (waveform player); recording waits for sub-project 7. Alternative: build recording now (needs an Opus/OGG encoder dependency). - **Q4 — Threads depth.** Build reading, posting, the chip, the side panel, creating from a message and the sidebar list; leave forums, thread browser filters and thread settings to 7. Alternative: everything now. - **Q5 — Search engines, translators, reverse image search.** Move these three chat-settings items and their context-menu entries to sub-project 7. Alternative: build them now. - **Q6 — Composer pills.** Accept coloured text instead of atomic pills (§15). Alternative: a custom editor widget (weeks of work, high risk). - **Q7 — Soundboard favourites (#92).** Sync them through the same `soundboard_picker` field of synced preferences in this sub-project. Alternative: keep them local. 🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)
charles added this to the Text chat milestone 2026-11-12 11:08:12 +00:00
Author
Owner

Q4 overruled by Charles (2026-11-12): forums and every other text channel type are in Text chat now, and threads must show their content. Spec §18 and plan Tasks 36–48 (#321–#333). Forum channel settings (tag create/edit, defaults) stay in sub-project 7; the protocol types for them are built now.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

Q4 overruled by Charles (2026-11-12): forums and every other text channel type are in Text chat now, and threads must show their content. Spec §18 and plan Tasks 36–48 (#321–#333). Forum channel settings (tag create/edit, defaults) stay in sub-project 7; the protocol types for them are built now. 🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)
Sign in to join this conversation.
No milestone
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference
charles/fluxer-native#286
No description provided.