Watch more than one stream large at the same time #935

Closed
opened 2026-11-19 06:40:46 +00:00 by charles · 2 comments
Owner

Forum feature request from Rhadamanthus (2026-11-19): "We can stream multiple sources but we can only view one of them at full res. I can add streams from multiple people, but I don't see a way to view more than one stream maximized."

Wanted: when watching streams from several people, a way to show two or more of them large side by side (each at its full subscribed quality), not one maximized with the rest as small tiles.

To decide before building: how the original client lays out several watched streams (grid vs one focused tile) and whether it requests full quality for each; what the layout does with three or more; how it interacts with the fullscreen view and the mini preview (#934). Check the fork checkout for the voice grid / focus logic first and match it where it already does this.

Forum feature request from Rhadamanthus (2026-11-19): "We can stream multiple sources but we can only view one of them at full res. I can add streams from multiple people, but I don't see a way to view more than one stream maximized." **Wanted:** when watching streams from several people, a way to show two or more of them large side by side (each at its full subscribed quality), not one maximized with the rest as small tiles. **To decide before building:** how the original client lays out several watched streams (grid vs one focused tile) and whether it requests full quality for each; what the layout does with three or more; how it interacts with the fullscreen view and the mini preview (#934). Check the fork checkout for the voice grid / focus logic first and match it where it already does this.
Author
Owner

Findings before building (agent working on branch feat-934-935-stream-view).

What the original does:

  • Layout mode is grid or focus (features/voice/state/VoiceCallLayout.ts). "Grid view" is a checkbox in the control bar's More options menu (VoiceSettingsMenus.tsx, VoiceMoreOptionsMenu, hidden in DM calls). In grid mode every tile is the same size (VoiceGridLayout, resolveVoiceGridPackedLayoutMetrics): the participants' tiles and the stream tiles, so two watched streams are shown large side by side together with the other tiles. "Show non-video participants" (same menu) can hide the tiles without video.
  • Focus mode pins one tile and shows the others in the mini grid. "Watch stream" (the tile button, the hover card, double-click) pins the stream and switches to focus (applyStreamWatchFocus, setPinnedParticipant). "Add stream" only watches and leaves the layout as it is. The layout mode is not stored across restarts.
  • Quality: every watched remote screen share is requested at quality: 'high' whatever its tile (voice_participant_tile/hooks.ts → watchStream({quality: 'high'})). There is no per-tile lower layer for streams.

What native does today: with no stream pinned, the call view is already the original's equal grid (call/grid.rs). Any newly watched stream gets pinned, though (call::State::sync), and there is no way back to the grid while watching. Subscriptions are on/off per track (set_subscribed). Screen shares are published without simulcast and the room joins with adaptive_stream = false, so every watched stream already arrives at its one full-quality layer, whatever the size of its tile.

What I will build:

  • A "More options" button (DotsThree, tooltip "More options") in the guild call's control bar, before Disconnect, with a "Grid view" toggle. In grid mode the call view shows the equal grid even while streams are watched and pinned. Focus mode is today's layout.
  • The choice is stored with the voice settings (call_layout, focus or grid; unknown values fall back to focus). As in the original, "Watch stream" (watch one stream alone) switches back to focus, and "Add stream" keeps the grid.
  • Fullscreen works from both layouts: in grid mode the grid fills the window, with the bar floating over it. The mini preview keeps showing the pinned stream, or else the one watched last.
  • No subscription change: each watched stream is already received at full quality (see above). The PR will say so.
  • "Show non-video participants" (which would leave only the stream tiles) is not built here. It will be a follow-up.
Findings before building (agent working on branch `feat-934-935-stream-view`). **What the original does:** - Layout mode is `grid` or `focus` (`features/voice/state/VoiceCallLayout.ts`). "Grid view" is a checkbox in the control bar's **More options** menu (`VoiceSettingsMenus.tsx`, `VoiceMoreOptionsMenu`, hidden in DM calls). In grid mode every tile is the same size (`VoiceGridLayout`, `resolveVoiceGridPackedLayoutMetrics`): the participants' tiles and the stream tiles, so two watched streams are shown large side by side together with the other tiles. "Show non-video participants" (same menu) can hide the tiles without video. - Focus mode pins one tile and shows the others in the mini grid. "Watch stream" (the tile button, the hover card, double-click) pins the stream and switches to focus (`applyStreamWatchFocus`, `setPinnedParticipant`). "Add stream" only watches and leaves the layout as it is. The layout mode is not stored across restarts. - Quality: every watched remote screen share is requested at `quality: 'high'` whatever its tile (`voice_participant_tile/hooks.ts` → `watchStream({quality: 'high'})`). There is no per-tile lower layer for streams. **What native does today:** with no stream pinned, the call view is already the original's equal grid (`call/grid.rs`). Any newly watched stream gets pinned, though (`call::State::sync`), and there is no way back to the grid while watching. Subscriptions are on/off per track (`set_subscribed`). Screen shares are published without simulcast and the room joins with `adaptive_stream = false`, so every watched stream already arrives at its one full-quality layer, whatever the size of its tile. **What I will build:** - A "More options" button (`DotsThree`, tooltip "More options") in the guild call's control bar, before Disconnect, with a "Grid view" toggle. In grid mode the call view shows the equal grid even while streams are watched and pinned. Focus mode is today's layout. - The choice is stored with the voice settings (`call_layout`, `focus` or `grid`; unknown values fall back to focus). As in the original, "Watch stream" (watch one stream alone) switches back to focus, and "Add stream" keeps the grid. - Fullscreen works from both layouts: in grid mode the grid fills the window, with the bar floating over it. The mini preview keeps showing the pinned stream, or else the one watched last. - No subscription change: each watched stream is already received at full quality (see above). The PR will say so. - "Show non-video participants" (which would leave only the stream tiles) is not built here. It will be a follow-up.
Author
Owner

Fixed in nightly 2026.1119.406.

Fixed in nightly 2026.1119.406.
Sign in to join this conversation.
No milestone
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference
charles/fluxer-native#935
No description provided.